RAID 0+1: LSM or LSM+AdvFS ?

From: A. Mahendra Rajah (Mahendra.Rajah@URegina.CA)
Date: Tue May 14 2002 - 13:19:22 EDT


   I have been tasked with setting up our disks farm in a
   RAID 0+1 configuration using software alone (no hardware
   RAID card!).

   We have an ES40 runnig Tru64v5.1A+pk1 that has 3 SCSI
   buses serving 16 disks. We run Oracle & Banner on this
   ES40 and all the file systems are AdvFS type.

   We have full licenses to run LSM and AdvFS. LSM is the
   only means of setting up RAID 1 (mirroring), but for RAID
   0 (striping) I am thinking that I could:

   1. Use sliced plexes in LSM, or

   2. Create every domain on a few disks and join them
       using AdvFS's 'addvol' command.

   I would like to solicit opinions from the list as to the
   best method to use. I think method 2 is more dynamic in
   that I can add more volumes as needed and also use
   AdvFS's 'balance' utility to balance out the contents of
   the domain. I could even stripe a large file across
   multiple volumes. (I am used to AdvFS commands and may be
   I am biased!)

   I don't see any advantage in doing 1, but the AdvFS
   Administration manual (Page 4-17) warns not to use AdvFS
   striping if LSM is already in use.

   Comments, suggestions or horror stories, please?

   Thanks,

   -- mahendra
.....................................................................
   A. Mahendra Rajah Email: Mahendra.Rajah@URegina.CA
   Tru64 UNIX Systems Manager Phone: (306) 585-4496
   Dept. of Computing Services FAX: (306) 585-5060
   University of Regina,
   Regina, Sask., S4S 0A2
   Canada.
.....................................................................



This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.7 : Sat Apr 12 2008 - 10:48:41 EDT